A Doha court has found a popular Turkish restaurant and five of its employees guilty of selling food unfit for human consumption and ordered the individuals to be jailed, fined and deported.
In a rare move, the Court of Environmental Misdemeanors also ordered that its verdict be published in Al Raya at the expense of the convicted individuals.
The conviction stems from an October 2014 incident in which several residents became ill after eating at the Bin Omran branch of fast-food restaurant Marmara Istanbul.
That includes a woman who was seven months pregnant and, after experiencing severe abdominal pain, had to be rushed to hospital and gave birth prematurely.
The woman’s husband and two other children who ate at the restaurant also sought medical treatment after experiencing “intense” nausea followed by diarrhea.
Following the incident, the Ministry of Municipality and Urban Planning (MMUP) ordered the eatery to close for some two months after inspecting its facilities.
At the time, the ministry published photos of what appeared to be dirty and moldy chopping boards, unclean worktops, BBQ grills blackened with caked-on food deposits and food lying around the surfaces.
The restaurant, which is located near TV Roundabout, has since reopened.
Sentence details
The convicted individuals, who had all pled not guilty, include:
- The restaurant manager, who was ordered to spend three months in jail and pay a fine of QR10,000;
- Three employees were ordered to spend a month in jail and a pay a QR7,000 fine; and
- Another employee responsible for obtaining health certification was given a harsher sentence totaling a month in jail and a fine of QR8,000.
All will be deported after serving their sentence. Additionally, the restaurant was fined QR32,000 and ordered to shut down for a further three months.
The defendants remain out of jail for now pending their appeal. It is not clear whether the closure is also dependent upon that outcome.
During the trial, which got underway last November, the court heard that inspectors from the Supreme Council of Health analyzed 41 food samples as well as swabs of surfaces inside the restaurant.
While most of the swabs came back negative, a half-dozen samples – including rice, corn salad, green salad, tabouleh, hummus and mayonnaise – tested positive for harmful levels of bacteria.
However, the samples were not taken until two days after the illnesses were reported.
While the apparent time gap was never explained during the trial, one of the lab technicians who took the swabs said the restaurant had been “cleaned up to perfection” by the time he arrived, according to his supervisor who testified during the trial.
Meanwhile, a defense lawyer told Doha News that the delay in testing meant any bacteria found on the food could have developed after it was removed from the restaurant. He repeated that argument outside court today.
The individuals and restaurant were convicted under a law that was amended in February 2014 to stiffen penalties for restaurants and food outlets caught breaching health and safety laws.
The trial also comes amid a push by the MMUP to further crack down on entries violating food regulations. That includes naming and shaming offenders by publicizing its enforcement actions against eateries.
All of the convicted individuals declined to comment after today’s verdict was read out, but their attorney said he will appeal the judgment in the next few weeks.
Thoughts?
i will never ever forget the pain i went through due to thier negligence :(. These guys deseve it .
Well done the MMUP and the courts, great to see. Now let’s see some enforcement on the roads, where the real damage is being done every single day.
They really deserve it !! I will never forget the day I went to Marmarat Istanbul with my friend, we ordered some sandwiches, my friend also bought some for his girlfriend ,the other day, all of us were at Hamad hospital with food poisoning !!! God job the MMUP .
We ate there regularly and never fell ill. At least once every two weeks.
I hope it is a good lesson for you. I went there once (AlSadd branch) and I knew I wouldn’t come back. Their shawarma was made of the leftover of chicken rather than proper chicken meat.
A good lesson to all restaurants who try to make huge profits at the expense of customers health. ..Hope similar checks are done on private health centres..
Ahh so your unfit fire precautions for a mall and the death of 19 people get you freedom and a job as an ambassador. Sell a bit of manky food and it’s jail time, deportation and a fine. Although I am pleased that this has actually been dealt with, perhaps they could deal with more pressing matters In a more appropriate way?
I can’t imagine that the management of the restaurant would allow it to get into such an appalling state for some economic reason – one must assume that they considered it to be “the norm” – and that’s pretty scary. I also assume that the Sponsor has no corporate responsibility and his only role in the operation of the restaurant is to bank his cut every month.
This is a very good point.
A whole debate could be opened up around this, but it might be reassuring if the sponsor is investigated to see if any other businesses are cutting corners and if any accountability should be laid at the sponsors feet?
Yeah. Well done MMUP. This can only be good for the food industry as it will make more restaurants up their game and ultimately good for the customers.
Why isn’t the owner punished? The people who run the show are only the front men for the joint.
If the owner doesn’t approve or initiate a healthier and a hygenic environment, how can the staff implement it?
As usual, logic doesn’t prevail.
The owner is probably a Qatari. Why punish him?
Punishment should be applied to the owner as well faux sho.
Thank god for that. This food could have killed somebody